Evidence supporting the use of: Menthol
For the health condition: Congestion
Synopsis
Source of validity: Scientific
Rating (out of 5): 2
Menthol is commonly used in over-the-counter remedies for nasal congestion, such as topical rubs, inhalers, and lozenges. Its use is based on both traditional practices and scientific investigation, but the scientific evidence for its efficacy is limited. Menthol does not actually decongest nasal passages by reducing swelling or mucus. Instead, it interacts with the cold-sensitive TRPM8 receptors in the nasal mucosa, producing a sensation of increased airflow and a cooling effect. This subjective sensation can make people feel as though their breathing is easier, even though objective measurements show no significant improvement in nasal airflow or actual decongestion.
Clinical studies have shown that while menthol provides a perception of relief, it does not significantly impact nasal airway resistance or true congestion. For instance, research published in the journal Chest (1988) concluded that menthol inhalation improved the subjective sensation of nasal patency without measurable physical benefit. Nonetheless, its ability to produce a cooling and soothing effect makes it a popular adjunct in cold remedies.
In summary, menthol's use for congestion is primarily supported by its sensory effects rather than any decongestant action. The scientific evidence rates as modest (2/5), largely due to its supportive role in symptom relief rather than in treating the underlying cause of congestion.
Other ingredients used for Congestion
allspicebasil
beta-pinene
betel
black currant
black pepper
chamomile
citrus oil
turmeric
echinacea purpurea
elderberry
garlic bulb
ginger
green tea
horseradish
licorice root
pomegranate
quercetin
rosemary
spearmint leaf
thyme
vitamin C
wasabia japonica
zinc
squawvine
hyssop
cardamom
atractylodes
mugwort
malabar nut
ferula assafoetida
anise
blackboard tree
lingusticum wallichii
buckthorn
lemongrass
yerba santa
coltsfoot
sweet flag
trichosanthes
birch
eucalyptus
menthol oil
Sichuan pepper
cayenne pepper
Alcohol
akebia
Agastache
Alpha-terpineol
Allicin
Asarum heterotropoides
Aconite
Asafoetida
Arisaema
Atractylone
Balsam
Bishop's Weed
Bayleaf
Barleria
Bitter Grass
berry
black salt
Bee products
Bombax
Buddha's Hand
Borneol
Camellia sinensis
Clerodendrum trichotomum
Citrus
Cineole
Cajuput
Chinese Raisintree
Cowherb
European Elder
Echinacea
Elder
Mallow
Vervain
Other health conditions supported by Menthol
Abdominal PainAllergies (respiratory)
Athletic and Exercise Aids
Backache
Bites and Stings
Bronchitis
Canker Sores
Colds (decongestant)
Colds (general)
Congestion
Congestion (bronchial)
Congestion (lungs)
Congestion (sinus)
Cough (dry)
Cough (general)
Cough (spastic)
Dermatitis
Digestion (poor)
Eczema
Exercise